2013 - Colten Claxton (Pictured right)
Submitted by Riddell All American

2012 - Brianna Wardyn
Submitted by J & H Athletic Equipment Reconditioning

2011 – Matthew Gloe from Wood River, Nebraska
Submitted by J & H Athletic Equipment Reconditioning

2010 – Christian Morgan from Grand Island, Nebraska
Submitted by J & H Athletic Equipment Reconditioning

2009 – Frank Rynkiewich from Evansville, Indiana
Submitted by Mercury Sports

2008 – Jamison Voss from Holstein, Iowa
Submitted by Riddell/All American

2007 – Amanda C. Skata from Honolulu, Hawaii
Submitted by Maxletics Sports

2006 - Aaron James Pomizel from Grand Island, Nebraska
Submitted by J & H Athletic Equipment Reconditioning

2005 – John Matthew Hodgson from Roeland Park Kansas
Submitted by Riddell/All American
2005 – Brian J. Eggers from Fort Collins, Colorado
Submitted by Harco
2004 - Alex Combs from Eaton, Ohio
Submitted by Capital Varsity